Why I won’t sign the ‘No Caste Reservation’ Petition…

This week, I received an email from a friend requesting me to sign a PIL that asks for cancellation of caste based reservations. Without giving it any second thought, I clicked on the link and signed my name. When it came to pushing the ‘submit’ button, my hand fell numb. My mind changed and I realized why I won’t be able to sign such a petition.

Read on…

Caste quota in India, that has benefited a great deal of people in getting admissions into premium colleges, blessed them with employment and inspired them in joining politics bringing them to the forefront, has shattered numerous dreams. I have heard of and known many who had to give up their dreams of getting into the college and studying the course of their choice. I know those who had interests in and were meritorious enough to pursue a course of MBBS but had to console their souls by taking up Pharmacy when they did not have the money to pay whopping donations nor the years to keep appearing for entrance examinations. And sadly, this happened when those with less merit and less interest got into the best of the institutions without any competition.

photo credit: techcrunch.com

There have been a plenty of bright, diligent and those who were both, who had to let go their ambitions and aspirations because we were reciting the chant of equality of castes. Every year, students with 70 % marks, 60% marks and sometimes 50% marks see doors open when all desirable doors are shut for those with 89% marks. Some of them decided to turn to other countries in order to follow their dreams.

Opportunities should exist for all, irrespective of marks. However, when we usher in the competition, let that remain fair.

When we speak of bridging the gap between high caste and low caste, what kind of equality are we trying to maintain? We are being plain unjust. Not all students falling into the low caste category need a reservation but all of them want. I refuse to believe that children born in a Dalit or a backward class family have any less efficient brain. And, do not put forth the point of their financial conditions, for we know how well they have been rising on that front. Many of them are much ahead of their high/general caste population. They have all the means to grow and get what they want. The irony is that they not only have seats reserved for them wherever they go, but are also provided low cost and no cost education.

I do feel agitated and angry about this but there’s a reason why my knees fall weak when standing against it.

The system of reservation is accountable for corruption. Given the easy lucrative opportunities it has to offer, forging of caste certificates is on the rise. Encouraging injustice and corruption is one more thing that this system has managed to succeed in. A system that doles out favours to you based on your birth is imperfect.

Fortunately, I have managed to survive without needing any reservation, so, I am probably not the right to person to tell the story. However, the angst persists and I’m sure millions will be ready to sign this petition.

Having vented my rants against the reservation, I still won’t sign this petition for the simplest of the reasons.

India is a country of villages. In our villages, the caste system bears an ugly face, to say the least. The population falling in the low caste category is deprived of education, employment and many times, the basic necessities of survival. This population still lives in poor conditions and faces the worst atrocities of inequality by its society.

It is pertinent that we bring them forward by encouraging them in the right way. Laws are written when people happen to ignore the unwritten rules and become inhumane. That’s exactly where we need reservation and that’s where gaps will be bridged without hurting others’ rights.

Follow this link to know what caste means in India and our thoughts will match.


photo credit: en.wikipedia.org

I hope I have answered my question. Any bill will have a domino effect. I doubt our system will take the pains of being selective in terms of cities and villages when passing a bill.

If the idea of giving a second thought to decisions is to be believed, I fall short of the courage that is required to sign such a petition. There’s nothing wrong in caring for the rights of our own people. This needs thinking and re-thinking by all sections of the society. On another note, I have yet to fathom what my choices would have been had I been sitting on the other side and whether my beliefs would have translated into actions.


13 thoughts on “Why I won’t sign the ‘No Caste Reservation’ Petition…

  1. Reservation probably is not the answer to help the poor or the downtrodden in the villages..Cause they dont use it..
    So why persist with a system that is not actually helping the ones who really need the help..
    And I understand given the dynamic of the country, decision making is tough.
    Reservation has become like the dowry laws of the country. In cities women have started using these laws to harass and blackmail men and families whereas in villages women are still burnt alive for dowry..
    Now laws cannot be different..But reservation laws can surely be..Based on the city/village dynamics and the financials reservation can be given but the current system is surely unjust for the majority…

    1. Yes. What I’ve been hoping for is a law that takes into account the circumstances as one solution doesn’t fit all. Look how this law has benefitted people in the cities.We are aware of the law because we are educated and even our disagreement with it doesn’t allow us to point fingers at those enjoying the privileges of this law.
      Improving the situations in villages is proving to be a herculean task, but it has to be done. We cannot see us growth when a majority is left behind.
      And believe me, I know how the weaker section of the society is treated in small cities and villages.Reservation is one thing but there has to be a strong solution.
      And while implementing such laws, we are expected to take care that undue advantage and misuse of the law is prevented.

      1. My point exactly.
        The current reservation is not helping the majority and hence the petition..Thou I have given up Hope on this issue. It will not be abolished soon. I am worried even my grandkids will suffer from this system..

  2. Sure of What?? about my grandkids suffering…God..your surity makes me feel older…Its gonna be long before I get grandkids.. 😉

  3. Ohh..wordpress and gravatar looks so tough…baap re
    I wrote a new blog today..See if you get a chance to visit…you can join the blog site to get updates..
    And if you share your email Id i can send you update emails when I update a blog..I have a list..
    Sab karna padta hai yaar..I wana be chetan bhagat someday..so need people to read my blog.. lol

  4. Very interesting post. Visiting others blogs from places beyond my space, had enlightened me in learning of other’s hardships and goodness. I tend to not sign petittions immediately. Made a mistake doing that one time.

  5. Excellent post .Some times we have to decide in a split second a fate of unknown.Thank you for liking my post ( Ariel /Monster. )Sincerely jalal

Leave your thoughts here!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s